Media misses the point with Ted Cruz


Ted Cruz, the junior senator from Texas, is the first Republican to officially announce his candidacy for president in 2016. His early endorsements include every registered Democrat in the United States. His early detractors should include every Republican who hopes their party can make a credible case for the White House.

And yet, the media (especially the lefties like CNN and MSNBC) seem to care more about two of the least important things about Cruz: where he was born, and where his healthcare comes from. Both should be debunked in favor of much larger concerns.

Ted Cruz is a U.S. citizen but was born in Canada, which some say poses a challenge in the face of the Constitution’s requirement that only a “natural born citizen” can run for president. Cruz renounced Canadian citizenship in May 2014 and has technically been a U.S. citizen since birth because of his American mother. Because of this, in the Harvard Law Review, Paul Clement, the solicitor general during George W. Bush’s second term as president, and Neal Katyal, who was an acting solicitor general for President Barack Obama, both argued there is “no question” that Cruz fulfills the natural born citizen requirement. Talking about Cruz’s natural born citizenship like it’s legitimately in question rips the rug out from under anyone who still wants to make fun of Donald Trump and the birthers for thinking Obama was born in Kenya.

The next straw man the media latched on to was Cruz’s announcement on CNN that he would sign up for health care through Obamacare’s exchange based in Washington, D.C. The press wasted no time lampooning him for signing up for the very service that he pledged “to repeal every word of,” but in reality, Cruz is only signing up for health insurance because he is no longer covered by his wife’s plan (she is taking a leave of absence from her job at Goldman Sachs in light of his run for the presidency). Cruz needs insurance, and he and his wife could either purchase a wildly expensive private plan, or they, like many Americans, could get it through Cruz’s status as a U.S. senator. In the former case, members of Congress must sign up through the law’s D.C. exchange. Cruz isn’t doing anything hypocritical — he’s just following the law.

Instead of chortling away with headlines like “Ted-I-Am Really Likes Obamacare,” CNN should devote its time to explaining the ramifications of Cruz’s call to repeal Obamacare. Doing so would kick millions of kids off their parents’ insurance, allow insurance companies to deny coverage to people with pre-existing conditions and permit insurers to stop paying for treatment of expensive illnesses like cancer once patients reach their coverage limit. Sounds a little more serious than being born in Canada, don’t you think?

Republicans, from the top donors, to the party leadership, to the voters, should avoid Cruz at all costs for two reasons. First, he will drag the entire party to the right in primary season and damage beyond repair whatever candidate ends up in the general election. He is radically socially conservative, and it doesn’t take much imagining to see him standing up at the first Republican primary debate, announcing his support for a Constitutional amendment to allow the states to make gay marriage illegal if they so choose and demanding the likes of Jeb Bush and Marco Rubio to raise their hands if they support it. If they don’t, they’ll lose the primary -— if they do, they’ll have no chance at winning the presidency.

Cruz is also a fierce denier of the belief that human-caused global warming represents a threat to the planet. He has compared believers of human-caused climate warming (which includes 97 percent of the scientific community) to “flat-earthers” and argued that the cold weather when he visited New Hampshire casts doubt on their beliefs. Again, a belief perhaps more dangerous than where Cruz gets his healthcare from.

When Cruz’s views aren’t threatening the planet’s survival, they are likely diminishing his chances to beat prospective Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton. This should, of course, seem obvious, but when the media on the left treats Cruz like a clown rather than someone who takes himself seriously and is revered by a substantial number of evangelical conservatives, they do themselves an enormous disservice.

Here’s why: Cruz’s chances of winning the presidency are about as likely as Vin Diesel’s Furious 7 winning the Oscar for Best Picture. Averaging the three national primary polls taken in March puts Cruz in eighth place with 4.6 percent of the vote. But, similar to Missouri senatorial candidate Todd Akin, who discussed his views of “legitimate rape” and had no chance of winning but single-handedly managed to tank the rest of the party’s chances in the 2012 midterms, Cruz could also sabotage the entire Republican field via guilt by association. Moreover, if his funding doesn’t run out, he can keep showing up in debates and on primary ballots. Harry Enten at FiveThirtyEight described the Cruz campaign as a “juicy rib-eye that robbers use to distract a guard dog during a heist.” Cruz’s candidacy has handed the media a gift on a silver platter, but they’re totally missing their chance to devour it.

Nathaniel Haas is a junior majoring in political science and economics. His column, “State of the Union,” runs  Fridays.

9 replies
  1. Electric Bill
    Electric Bill says:

    I hope Cruz stays in the race as long as any deep-pocketed jackasses are willing to waste their greenbacks on him. He’s a gift from the gods to SNL, and every stand up comedian itching to make a name for himself at the Laugh Factory.

    Whether it be conservative or liberal, people need to slash past the Paper Tigers and get to the true meats of the issues, rather than trumpeting about snow in the Northwest in Spring, or inane birthed issues. We NEED healthcare. The Obama care system is flawed and ripe for criticism, but nothing more. It is far better than what existed before, the GOP does nothing more than insist on throwing out the baby with the bathwater and putting us in a much worse situation than we had before Obama are was passed. The GOP does not offer anything to replace Obamacare, the present plan for immigration reform, taxation or any other genuine issue: all they ever do is block, filibuster, complain, criticize and whine, without actually offering a trace of a solution to any of the issues!

    Has Boehner EVER offered a point-by-point alternative to healthcare? To immigration and border control? To taxation reform, other than continually widening the door through which trillions of dollars flow to the ultra-rich, while the middle and lower class income and standard of living continue to slide?

    When Dubbya left office, he left us with an economy in the toilet, the stock market stagnant, unemployment at its worst. All they have ever talked about is, what a terrible prez Obama is, and blocked anything he ever tried to do, despite the fact that unemployment is not lower than it’s been in nearly a decade, more people have health care now than ever before, there is a genuine effort to lock down our borders, and all Boehner and the rest can do is complain about imaginary issues.

    Sickening.

    No, Hillary Clinton’s not perfect. She irritates me on occasion with her control-freak style. But she’s a thousand times better than any of the alternatives such as Cruz, Bush, et al., who can offer us nothing more than whimpering, pouting and foot-stomping.

  2. Thekatman
    Thekatman says:

    Cruz is a natural born US citizen because his mother is a natural born citizen. It doesn’t matter where you were born.

    This article must’ve been written by the political hacks at the DNC, because it’s content has been copy / pasted straight out of their playbook.

    Mos t people want the ACA repealed in favor of a worthwhile healthcare plan. Obamacare is control and wealth redistribution disguised as healthcare And is designed to bankrupt the Healthcare industry so that the Feds can take full control via a single payor plan. Think you choices are limited now?

    The bullet points the writer mentone like pre existing conditions, stay on your parents plan until 26 years of age, etc, would be kept in the new plan. That’s a given.

    • RexRowland
      RexRowland says:

      “Cruz is a natural born US citizen because his mother is a natural born citizen. It doesn’t matter where you were born.
      This article must’ve been written by the political hacks at the DNC, because it’s content has been copy / pasted straight out of their playbook.”

      Did you NOT read the part where the author is saying Cruz is an American citizen and that it shouldn’t be a story? No, you didn’t. You went headlong into this article like the ideological conservative hack that you are, already having a statement prepared, even if it had nothing to do with what was written.

  3. lgstarn
    lgstarn says:

    “Cruz needs insurance, and he and his wife could either purchase a wildly expensive private plan, or they, like many Americans, could get it through Cruz’s status as a U.S. senator”

    Thank you for this unintentional hilarity.

    Just how many Americans can get insurance through status as a U.S. senator? It really can’t be more than 100 families, one would think.

    “Like many Americans, I am Bill Gates.”

    • RexRowland
      RexRowland says:

      Mosty libbies know Cruz is eligible for President. The issue is calling out the same conservatives who to this day think Obama is not eligible for the SAME EXACT REASONS they think Cruz IS eligible. Even if Obama was born in Kenya (he wasn’t), his mother was still born in Wichita. Period. Surely conservatives are going to be just as harsh and dedicated to questioning Cruz’s legitimacy as Obama’s, right? Of course conservatives would NEVER be shameless, outright hypocrites.

  4. Slovo Thompson
    Slovo Thompson says:

    Simple. He was NOT BORN IN THE UNITED STATES! Now if the dumbass didn’t know that before stepping up,,,, Then he needs to STEP OFF! We have enough idiots pretending to run this country as it is, we don’t need some foreign asshole joining the mix.
    Sorry Canada, I do think you are a great and cool country, but please restrain your idiots!

  5. Christopher Barnhouse
    Christopher Barnhouse says:

    Don’t worry,l there’s plenty of time to focus on all the crazy Cruz crap. His Obamacare coverage and citizenship are low hanging fruit.

Comments are closed.