DC Animation continues to overpower Marvel

Ever since director Zack Snyder hinted that his upcoming Man of Steel sequel, still tentatively titled Batman vs. Superman, would serve as a direct lead-in to the long-rumored Justice League movie, fans have accused Warner Bros. and DC Entertainment of rushing things in order to replicate the phenomenal crossover success of Marvel’s The Avengers. Others have lambasted DC for allowing its rival to take the lead in the first place, citing the abysmal Green Lantern and other failed attempts to expand its stable of heroes beyond Batman and Superman as proof that Marvel’s meticulous world-building model can’t be topped.

A League of Their Own · Batman, voiced by Jason O’Mara, and his fellow superheroes must unite against interdimensional tyrant Darkseid, voiced by Steve Blum in Justice League: War. - Photo courtesy of Warner Bros.

A League of Their Own · Batman, voiced by Jason O’Mara, and his fellow superheroes must unite against interdimensional tyrant Darkseid, voiced by Steve Blum in Justice League: War. – Photo courtesy of Warner Bros.

Both of those criticisms are perfectly valid, so long as we’re talking about live-action films. With the exception of Christopher Nolan’s groundbreaking Dark Knight trilogy, DC has struggled to match Marvel’s glib, fanciful energy and its ability to create an intricate yet accessible “shared universe.” Yet the exact opposite holds true for the field of animation, where DC has been dominating its old foe for more than two decades.

While Marvel Animation seems content to cater mainly to younger fans with programs such as Disney XD’s Ultimate Spider-Man and The Super Hero Squad Show, the DC animated universe offers everything from Bruce Timm and Paul Dini’s highly influential Batman: The Animated Series and Justice League to stunning feature-length adaptations of Frank Miller’s classic The Dark Knight Returns and Geoff Johns’ acclaimed Flashpoint storyline.

For years, one of the only major complaints about DC animation was its lack of a single unified line of continuity. That changed last week with the release of Justice League: War, the newest installment of the ongoing DC Universe Animated Original Movie series and the first to be set within DC Comics’ still-controversial “New 52” continuity, a rebooted timeline designed to streamline decades of cluttered narratives and draw in a new generation of readers.

Based on the first run of Geoff Johns and Jim Lee’s Justice League: Origin comic — the same series that launched the “New 52” back in Fall 2011 — Jay Oliva’s film follows Batman (Jason O’Mara) as he encounters Superman (Firefly’s Alan Tudyk) and the Green Lantern (Justin Kirk) for the first time while hunting down a cabal of interdimensional kidnappers in the employ of the evil deity Darkseid, played by voice-over maestro Steve Blum. The ensuing battle between the superheroes and Darkseid’s legion of “Parademons” ultimately leads to the formation of the Justice League, including founding members Wonder Woman (Michelle Monaghan), The Flash (Christopher Gorham), Cyborg (Shemar Moore) and Shazam (The Lord of the Rings’ Sean Astin).

Producer James Tucker recently announced that DC intends to release three straight-to-DVD animated features every year. Two of them will take place within the same continuity and the third will either be an original story with DC characters or an adaptation of a pre-existing work. Some adaptations will be brought into the new continuity, including this May’s Son of Batman, which takes Grant Morrison and Andy Kubert’s celebrated 2006 graphic novel Batman and Son and repurposes it as the follow-up to Justice League: War. Another upcoming project, this fall’s Batman: Assault on Arkham, will apparently take place within the world of the massively popular Arkham Asylum video games.

Son of Batman, directed by Avatar: The Last Airbender veteran Ethan Spaulding, is shaping up to be the most exciting of DC’s 2014 releases for a number of reasons. First of all, it will feature the animated debut of Damian Wayne, Batman’s fourth Robin and the genetically perfected offspring of Bruce Wayne and supervillainess Talia al Ghul. Despite being a relatively recent addition to the Bat family, this caustic, pint-sized assassin became an immediate fan favorite in the comics, and the outcry over his death in the pages of Morrison’s Batman, Inc. made international headlines last year.

If the idea of Batman discovering that he has a 10-year-old son who’s been trained to kill from birth by the League of Assassins fails to pique your interest, you might want to consider turning in your geek card. The film also boasts a surprisingly high-caliber voice cast, including the great Giancarlo Esposito as immortal arch-criminal Ra’s al Ghul. Esposito might have been talked into pursuing the role by his Breaking Bad co-star Bryan Cranston, who gave an excellent performance as then-Lieutenant Jim Gordon in 2011’s Batman: Year One.

While its animation team busies itself with a seemingly inexhaustible supply of new projects, DC is also making significant inroads with other mediums, including live-action TV. The CW’s Arrow has proven itself a surprise hit with an increasingly rabid fanbase — giving the series a distinct advantage over Marvel’s disappointing Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. on ABC — and shows based on The Flash, obscure do-gooder Hourman, chain-smoking occult detective John Constantine and Jim Gordon’s early years as a Gotham City detective are already in development. The superhero craze has officially expanded to the small screen and VOD markets, and DC is taking the lead at a pace worthy of the Scarlet Speedster himself.


2 replies
  1. Lucca
    Lucca says:

    While EMH was a good show storywise, the animation was awful and very low budget (to the point that characters were off model or missing limbs and had glaring coloring errors in some scenes). Besides Marvel cancelled EMH for Avengers Assemble, a show which is inferior in the writing department and even worse in animation (there are scenes where the characters look like they are carboard standees in motion and a lot of lazy computer generated scenes).

    Ultimate Spider-Man and Wolverine and The X-Men is probably the only Marvel cartoon that I can think of that had decent animation and even then Ultimate Spider-Man’s quality has significantly gone down.

    And even with the cancellation of those shows (which was more the fault of Cartoon Network exec than DC’s) DC still dominating the animation market with the Direct to DVD stuff (which is selling really well) and they show some of those movies in CN so they do reach wider demographics as well.

    Not to mention the DC Nation shorts, they were a thing of beauty

  2. Jaystaar
    Jaystaar says:

    Excuse me, you seem to have forgotten to acknowledge the cancellation of “Young Justice” and “Green Lantern TAS” not to mention the uncertain future of “Beware the Batman”. Marvel can do animated shows that skew a wider demographic. “Avengers: EMH” and a few of it’s “X-men” series spring to mind. Marvel might be squandering talent there but at least it’s doing stuff with it’s characters. DC on the other is practically dissmising all of it’s efforts for the sake of focusing all it’s creative input into TTgo! Kindly explain that!

Comments are closed.