Calif. Supreme Court upholds Proposition 8

By Kate Mather · Summer Trojan

Posted May 27, 2009 at 5:53 am in News

 

gay marriageThe California Supreme Court upheld Proposition 8 Tuesday, affirming the ban on same-sex marriage that voters approved last year.

While the justices were split 6-1 regarding the constitutionality of the proposition — which was passed with a 52 percent vote in November’s election — they unanimously agreed that the marriages of as many as 18,000 same-sex couples will be recognized under state law.

In the majority decision, Chief Justice Ronald M. George wrote that because same-sex couples still have the right to civil unions, Prop 8 did “not entirely repeal or abrogate” their right to “choose one’s life partner and enter with that person into a committed, officially recognized and protected family relationship that enjoys all of the constitutionally based incidents of marriage.”

Rather, George wrote, voters chose to reserve the “official designation of the term ‘marriage’ for the union of opposite-sex couples as a matter of state constitutional law.”

In addition to rejecting arguments that Prop 8 was an illegal constitutional revision, the court also denied contentions that the proposition unconstitutionally affected an inalienable right.

While justices said it was “inappropriate” to decide whether or not same-sex marriages performed outside California would be recognized by the state, they voted to uphold existing California marriages that took place before Prop 8 was passed. 

“The marriages of same-sex couples performed prior to the effective date of Proposition 8 remain valid and must continue to be recognized in this state,” George wrote.

Despite this decision, protests broke out in cities across the state — including San Francisco and Los Angeles — as opponents of Prop 8 expressed their dismay that the decision was upheld.

At USC, however, many students said they were not surprised by the decision.

“It’s never a good thing to hear that you’ve had your rights taken away from you, but it honestly was less of a surprise after the whole Prop 8 thing,” said Chris Dunford, one of the founders of the Equal Marriage Rights Initiative at USC, a new organization founded on campus after Prop 8 was approved.

Genevieve Flores, executive director of USC’s Gay Lesbian Bisexual Transgender Assembly, said while she was not surprised by the ruling, she had hoped the court would intervene.

“Honestly, the Supreme Court should have stepped in,” Flores said. “It’s usually up to the Supreme Court to uphold the rights of minorities.”

In a statement from USC College Republicans, Director of Public Relations Lauren Korbatov said while group members had different political opinions regarding Prop 8, the organization agreed with the legal decision made by the court.

“The California Supreme Court ruled today that Proposition 8 was a legal constitutional amendment passed by California voters, and we agree with the legal merits of this assessment,” the statement said. “Our membership has diverse views on the political debate surrounding Proposition 8, and we therefore do not endorse a position on the political aspects of the controversy.”

Political experts said the future of Prop 8 is still unclear, as many opponents have vowed to again present the proposition to voters again — including in the upcoming 2010 election.

Flores agreed, saying it was up to voters to repeal Prop 8.

“The ball’s back in our court,” Flores said.

Comments are closed.

More News

  Daily Trojan Spring Awakening Supplement

Blogs

Daily Trojan Poll

Which headliner did you enjoy most at Springfest?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Archives

May 2009
S M T W T F S
    Jun »
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31  

Browse Archives

News

SPECIAL FEATURE: Prof loses tenure bid after appeal

On April 3, Assistant Professor of International Relations Mai’a Keapuolani Davis Cross, who had traveled cross-country from her tenure track position at Colgate University to ...

Center to host more concerts after deal with Nederlander

The Galen Center entered into a deal last week with Nederlander Concerts, a Los Angeles-based company that organizes concerts with venues, to increase the numbers ...

Annenberg creates community pay phones

A group of USC students, community members and local artists in Leimert Park are bringing the pay phone back into service — and hoping to ...

Opinion

’SC sets example in lowering dropout rate

A report sponsored by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation reveals that the nation’s higher education system is facing a dropout crisis. Produced in part ...

Should the Guantánamo Bay prison remain open?

The prison must be closed as it stands for hypocrisy and infringes upon international human rights.  One hundred of the total 166 inmates at the Guantánamo ...

The Internet celebrates 20th birthday

Tuesday marked the 20th anniversary of the creation of World Wide Web. The organization responsible for building the Internet, CERN, also created the Large Hadron ...

Sports

Trojans begin three-game homestand against TCU

As the USC baseball team enters the final month of its baseball season 11 games under .500, it can at least feel good that it ...

USC faces North Florida in first round of tournament

For the No. 4 USC women’s sand volleyball team, its entire season has led up to this tournament. The team will finally be put to the ...

Jovan, Monica Vavic earn league awards

When it comes to dominating the competition in the pool, nobody does it better than the Vavic family. Following a season in which head coach ...

Lifestyle

An Exercise in Authenticity

Though Generation Um…includes a star studded cast—Keanu Reeves, Bojana Novakovic, and Adelaide Clemens—this film surprisingly has more of an indie vibe.  Set in New York ...

History behind shakes

Though finals loom as obstacles between now and summer, Ground Zero Performance Café has the perfect solution for both cooling down and serving your study ...

Play creates darker version of J.M. Barrie’s classic tale

Before Disney’s Peter, Wendy, John and Michael flew over “poor Nana” toward Big Ben and continued to the second star to the right and straight ...

Photos

In Photos: Washington comes to USC

In Photos: Washington comes to USC

The Schwarzenegger Institute held an immigration reform forum titled "Washington comes to USC", with U.S Senators John McCain, Michael Bennet and former President of Mexico ...

In Photos: Armenian Genocide

Photos by Ani Kolangian [gallery link="file" ids="66554,66555,66556,66557,66558,66559,66560,66561,66562"]

In Photos: Springfest 2013

Photos by Priyanka Patel. [gallery link="file" ids="65587,65586,65585,65584,65583,65582,65581,65580,65579,65578,65577,65576"]