The BCS gives USC an uphill climb

By Michael Middlehurst-Schwartz · Daily Trojan

Posted October 19, 2009 at 11:08 pm in Columns, Sports

With the release of the first Bowl Championship Series standings, every contender in college football is plotting the complex path it would take to get to the championship game.

And the world keeps spinning.

The October release is like clockwork; a whole bunch of numbers that mean nothing to the average college football fan is thrown out to justify a new hierarchy that leaves everyone bewildered. Now, the fiercest team loyalists have to have a nationwide consciousness of the game in order to understand their team’s place in the bigger picture.

There are too many games left to be played for any fans to start worrying about their chances at this point in the season. But USC fans had to be a little bit mystified when the Trojans debuted at No. 7 in the standings, despite being ranked No. 4 in both the AP and Coaches polls.

And while there’s the expected question of what it would take to get the Trojans to the Jan. 8 game in the Rose Bowl instead of the boring Jan. 1 version that they’re accustomed to, there’s another, more interesting scenario at hand. USC’s best chance to make it to the title game would also provoke more rumblings of an uprising from schools that felt jilted by the system.

As it stands, most prognosticators are calling for Texas to play the winner of the Southeastern Conference in the title game, a clean outcome that those affiliated with the BCS would love. After so many years of bad publicity, a year without controversy would help take some of the heat off the embattled system.

Of course, you don’t really need a system to pair together two undefeated teams at the end of the year, but the powers that be would probably like to remain behind the curtain on this one.

But considering that there hasn’t been a title clash between undefeated teams since USC met Texas in the 2006 Rose Bowl, there’s always room for a little doubt. With the way the first half of the season has played out, the uncertainty would mean ugliness for college football.

Each of the three teams ahead of USC have been surprises in the early part of the season; few would have predicted Boise State, Cincinnati and Iowa to be this high in the polls at this point in the year. But all have potential pitfalls that could hurt them in the rankings.

The talk surrounding Boise State is if “the little team that could” might actually make a case for the national championship game. But with an uninspiring schedule remaining, the Broncos could get jumped repeatedly in the standings by teams who have more to offer on a weekly basis. In fact, there’s talk of TCU taking Boise State’s bid if the Horned Frogs win out, because they play against more impressive teams and in a more highly regarded conference.

Despite having the label of a major conference team, Cincinnati has been treated like a cute sideshow by most of the college football world. The Bearcats face similar challenges in perception as Boise State, though they get more respect for playing in the Big East Conference.

But even with an undefeated season Cincinnati would be impervious to being leapfrogged by one-loss teams like USC.

Iowa provides the most interesting obstacle, because the Big Ten Conference still has enough prestige behind it, despite being battered in the national spotlight repeatedly over the last three years. An unbeaten Hawkeyes team would be an attractive option if the Texas-SEC arrangement falls through. Scoreboard watchers will likely have their eyes on a Nov. 14 date with Ohio State, and USC fans will likely be asking for a favor from the team whose heart they’ve broken the last two years.

If the Texas-SEC marriage doesn’t pan out, the BCS will be forced to make an unpopular decision and pick among a horde of flawed teams. And though the system is here to stay, plenty of schools would at least temporarily make their voices heard in the campaign against the BCS.

Of course, none of this matters if USC doesn’t win out. With only Pac-10 games remaining, any slip up would cost the Trojans not only a shot at the national title game but also the conference crown.

Given that uncertainty, it’s probably best for USC fans to tune out the numbers talk for a few weeks and check back in if the Trojans are still undefeated after a Halloween game against Oregon. The final month will be more telling than any predictions available now.

And, if the system is still unintelligible to you, don’t feel bad. Number-crunchers such as Brad Edwards and Jerry Palm make careers out of interpreting the system.

Maybe USC should start offering “BCS analysis” as a major — it’s going to be needed almost every year.

“Tackling Dummy” runs Tuesdays. To comment on this article, visit dailytrojan.com or email Michael at middlehu@usc.edu

Comments are closed.

More News

Current Weather

FairLA Downtown, CA
50°F (feels like 50°F)
Weather data provided by weather.com®

Daily Trojan Poll

What are you plans for Spring Break?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Archives

October 2009
S M T W T F S
« Sep   Nov »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Browse Archives

News

Changing hands

Changing hands

Students purchase cell phones, iPods and other items at the Department of Public Safety’s lost and found sale Wednesday. About 200 people showed up to ...

USG-funded speaker event draws criticism

Students from a variety of ideologies are coming together in protest of the Undergraduate Student Government’s decision to provide funding to help bring a controversial ...

College Democrats, Republicans square off at debate

Political debate was in full swing Wednesday night as students filled the room in Waite Phillips Hall to hear campus political groups debate President Obama’s ...

DPS, Latino Student Assembly discuss race

When Luis Garcia Rico was riding his bike to Wing Stop one night for a quick dinner during finals, he saw flashing lights behind him. ...

University earns spot on community service honor roll

USC was recently named to President Obama’s 2010 Higher Education Community Service Honor Roll for its students’ work in the surrounding neighborhood, but community service ...

Cheng, Ogbevoen name new USG executive officers

Undergraduate President-elect Chris Cheng and Vice President-elect Nehi Ogbevoen announced their 2010-2011 executive officers at Tuesday’s Senate meeting, marking their first official decision since winning ...

Opinion

USG should sponsor both sides of debate

The university setting is an ideal forum for viewpoints from all political, cultural and ideological arenas; colleges across the country have a storied history of ...

Is procrastination really that bad? I’ll find out later

Well into midterm season, college students across campus feel the stress of studying for exams and the anxiety that comes with testing. But while hours ...

Farmers market offers unique experience

A Tuesday walk down University Avenue is no longer just a monotonous commute to and from class. It’s an experience. The farmers market, which was previously located ...

Master plan will affect community ties

Last week, President Obama included USC on the President’s Higher Education Community Service honor roll, along with 700 other universities. This honor validates the unique quality ...

On-campus social scene needs a life

Department of Public Safety Chief Carey Drayton said he has high hopes for the new Ronald Tutor Campus Center. He thinks the building’s opening in ...

Alternative spring breaks are worthwhile

If you’ve ever suffered through one of MTV’s raucous spring break specials, you might conclude that all college students make a yearly pilgrimage to Cabo ...

Sports

Women of Troy travel to NCAA championships

The No. 9 USC women’s swimming and diving team will fly to Purdue, Ind., on Monday to compete in the NCAA championship meet. After the team’s ...

Trojans have full schedule during break

The USC track and field team will have plenty of ways to keep busy over spring break. With the Northridge Invitational beginning Friday and the ...

USC gets double dose of Cougars away from home

The No. 7 USC men’s volleyball team will travel to Utah this spring break, as it visits No. 4 Brigham Young University for back-to-back games ...

East Coast swing for streaking Trojans

Fresh off a dominating 5-2 victory over Wake Forest on Wednesday, the No. 3 USC men’s tennis team will be heading east for two matches ...

Highly ranked field in store for Trojans

Calling itself the host of the best field in college golf, the Southern Highlands Collegiate will welcome 11 of the nation’s top 20 golf teams, ...

Errors and unearned runs prove costly

University of Connecticut third baseman Mike Olt’s ninth inning double off the glove of USC senior centerfielder Mike O’Neill knocked in the game-winning run as ...

Lifestyle

South Korean film finds humor in cruelty

South Korean film finds humor in cruelty

Mothers are strange beasts. Their relationships with their children are far more complex and imperfect than most realize until they are parents themselves. Some women ...

Weekend picks

thursday, march 11 Navigating the Film Festival World Seminar for Filmmakers 7:30 p.m. > Egyptian Theatre > $15 For budding filmmakers and future film critics, this informative ...

Gorillaz’s latest shows off pop music at its finest

Gorillaz’s newest release, Plastic Beach, is unmistakably pop. But confined to current and somewhat mistaken definitions of the genre, this is either an insult or just ...

Blogging provides students a soapbox

This week I did something that I never thought I would do — I started a blog. Blogging has become a nearly ubiquitous hobby for our ...

Documentary spotlights art-heist drama

In a world of corruption, avarice and back-room deals, a fervent debate has been raging between warring parties for years. Since art became a business, ...

Soundtrack mixes Disney pop and eerie rock

A curious conglomeration of artists came together to form the questionable but well-meaning backtrack to Tim Burton’s latest cinematic creation. After watching Alice in Wonderland ...