Clichés inevitable in likening cities

By Clare Sayas · Daily Trojan

Posted November 4, 2009 (3 weeks ago) at 11:30 pm in Columns, Lifestyle

There are two destinations where dreamers go to pursue wealth and fame: If you’re reading this, you’ve probably chosen Los Angeles. The other city, LA’s older sibling, still serves as a destination for wide-eyed youths yearning to make it big: New York City, which, on this side of the country, can inspire either wonder and excitement or a slew of cuss words.

Of course, as is inevitable with siblings, there is a marked degree of rivalry between the two satellite cities. When simplified to mere snapshots of each other, Los Angeles and New York City represent totally opposite and incompatible ways of life. But as disparate as the cities appear, in some strange and unexpected moments, the two cities can come together in mystical unison.

When Angelenos visit the Big Apple, they expect to find the cliché New York City crafted in Hollywood back lots for films like Ghostbusters, Sex and the City and The Godfather. But surprisingly, a piece of Los Angeles can be found on Broadway, playing full blast in the Brooks Atkinson Theatre.

Tony-nominated jukebox musical Rock of Ages threatened to “melt [my] face” with its songbook filled with mid-to-late ’80s arena rock — the thrusting, soaring kind the entire graduate school and the elder half of the undergraduate population was conceived to.

This hokey musical follows the story of a young, wannabe rocker Drew, played by the disconcertingly tall American Idol alumnus and LA-manufactured quasi-celeb Constantine Maroulis, and his unemployed actor love interest, Sherrie (played by fresh-faced Kerry Butler), who come to Los Angeles from middle America to, expectedly, get famous.

This plot is a familiar motif to New York City-based musicals as well — think of 42nd Street — but Broadway’s take on the Sunset Strip as a lawless, inefficient and hedonistic city where fragile souls can fall by the wayside is a syncretic production of city spirits.

Musicals are synonymous with the New York City character, and seeing that vision of its sister city as a loud, unoriginal but thoroughly pleasurable spectacle blends both cities’ stereotypical characteristics with the aid of some screaming guitar and good old Poison.

Rock of Ages isn’t just a love story, though — Drew and his cronies have to fight against European developers that have bribed corrupt LA politicians in order to knock out Sunset Boulevard’s rock clubs, including the famous one Drew sweeps the floor of, the Bourbon Room. Regina (Lauren Molina), the city’s Berkeley import, rallies her fellow Angelenos to bring the noise and protest the threat to this sacred institutions of binge drinking, inappropriate behavior in bathroom stalls and men with very tight and very sparkly pants.

This image of dated, silly excess as the essence of Los Angeles isn’t new, but the fact that it has been brought to a New York City stage and recognized in the snooty Tony Award circle is an admission to LA’s shared values with New York City. Though the musical’s fluffy yet hopeful show did not garner any Tony wins, the nominations meant an admission that maybe LA culture isn’t so bad.

The two cities have more in common than some of its dwellers would like to admit. There are characteristics that all urban places share, like the poverty, social stratification and age-old grime that pervades the city: graffiti-laden walls.

But it’s New York City’s iconic visual vocabulary that has cemented itself in the minds of society because of its emotional stimulus on the human conscious. It’s a city not built on rock‘n’roll and excess like Los Angeles, but a city with all sorts of people coexisting in cramped quarters and subway schedules, speaking in all sorts of languages at once. We’ve seen and heard New York City as a state of mind, a musical wonder, a runaway’s anonymous oasis and site for natural disaster, horrible crime and as a destructible playground for all sorts of giant monsters, faithfully presented by Hollywood.

Los Angeles and New York City have the same conception of each other as dirty, cracked and decrepit — inferior in some way or another. Los Angeles lacks real culture, while New York City lacks nature; Los Angeles has no organization while New York City has too much. They have theater and opera, while we have faultlines and TV tapings.

But where both cities come together is a love of an entertainment that moves, of images that influence and of symphonies that do their best to transform. We juxtapose the highbrow and lowbrow: The bustling pretzel cart across the way from the New York City Ballet is just like the ubiquitous “death dog” vendor that feed the season-ticket holding execs outside of the Staples Center. The same street musician plays the soundtrack of the end of our nights, a weary, wistful saxophone, guitar or harmonica riffing on a popular song recognized in both cities.

Sure, one man’s elevator is another’s freeway, one coast’s biweekly surf is another’s Central Park jog and one city’s farmers’ market is another’s Dean and Deluca, but the two feed on each other for the stories both cities love to tell to the rest of America. They are the two voices that the country looks to for inspiration.

So play nice, New York City and Los Angeles. No matter how you get to work or what books you read, you’ll find yourself singing along to the same cheesy song, remembering your own dreams and why you chose your city in the first place.

Clare Sayas is a junior majoring in public relations. Her column, “Lost & Found,” runs Thursdays.

2 Comments on “Clichés inevitable in likening cities”

  1. Got2bme

    I’m not sure Rock Of Ages’ Tony Award Nominations meant an admission that maybe LA culture isn’t so bad, as you suggest. It is the setting for the show, but this show is about the music and the performance, not a statement about Los Angeles one way or the other. The nominations were about the artistic achievement of the show and its brilliant performers. Fake, plastic and overrated Los Angeles needs to get over itself.

  2. John Hupp

    The title of this piece is quite telling—any attempt to compare and contrast Los Angeles and New York is ultimately futile. LA is a fragmented collection of many different perceptions, and NYC has four boroughs that are not Manhattan. Summarily comparing the Sunset Strip to Broadway or Times Square is so silly as to be comical.

    You’re right about one thing: New York and LA are both dirty and run down. If you want a city where they actually scrape the gum off the sidewalks, go to Chicago.

More News

Current Weather

FairLA Downtown, CA
67°F (feels like 67°F)
Weather data provided by weather.com®

Daily Trojan Poll

Do you think it is reasonable to ban potential protestors at the Horowitz event? Story >

  • No, I think that everyone's voice deserves to be heard. (41%, 27 Votes)
  • Yes, I think that Horowitz deserves to be heard without distractions or safety concerns. (32%, 21 Votes)
  • I think that Horowitz should not be allowed to speak in the first place. (27%, 19 Votes)

Total Voters: 66

Loading ... Loading ...

Archives

November 2009
S M T W T F S
« Oct    
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  

Browse Archives

News

Organizers postpone inaugural ‘undie run’

Everyone looking forward to blowing off some pre-finals steam by sprinting through campus wearing very little clothing will have to wait another semester. This semester, three ...

LAPD takes new approach to enforcing bike laws

The Los Angeles Police Department took a slightly different approach to Wednesday’s traffic enforcement operation near USC’s campus than it took during its September effort. At ...

USG event brings presidents together

Student leaders from across campus met under the Undergraduate Student Government banner Wednesday night at USG’s first Council of Presidents, an event bringing together executive ...

A burger a day keeps the apples away

For America’s largest universities, achieving a nutritiously balanced campus is a lot harder than it looks. With each student comes a different set of eating ...

USC, embattled County hospital tread murky water

Situated two miles away from the heart of Los Angeles, the Los Angeles County and USC County Hospital serves a population of about 1.2 million ...

Bikes mounting, it’s time to break the cycle

At high noon on Trousdale Parkway, the walkway is choked by the ritual lunch rush. Among the maze of legs slides a pair of wheels ...

Opinion

Task force shouldn’t dismiss breast health

Task force shouldn’t dismiss breast health

Here is an important message most women in America have heard for the majority of their lives: Get mammograms every one to two years in ...

Seven habits of highly ineffective governors

With Gov. Schwarzenegger’s second term about to wrap up, several names have begun to surface as his possible replacement, with California Attorney General Jerry Brown ...

Americans focused on the wrong hunger problem

Can you believe it’s been one year? A full 365 days! Fifty-two weeks! Two seasons of G’s to Gents! Yes, believe it or not, an entire year has passed ...

Fliers buy offsets for their guilt

Last month, “Responsible Travel” aborted its nine-year initiative allowing airplane passengers to purchase carbon offsets to compensate for jet fuel emissions — a program that ...

Letter to the Editor

Right of way I was excited to see the issue of pedestrian safety and traffic code infringement make front-page news on Wednesday, Nov. 18. The article ...

Bike regulation requires a more cohesive plan

Today, many student cyclists will dismount and walk their bikes through the two major intersections along Jefferson Boulevard, under the threat of a ticket. But tomorrow, ...

Sports

Trojan seniors see their USC careers come full circle

Trojan seniors see their USC careers come full circle

More than three years ago, the newest USC men’s water polo team members began their careers with a 10-4 victory over UC Irvine at McDonald’s ...

Playing injured not worth the risks

The senior had been waiting his whole life for this moment. Ever since his high school football team lost in the state championship last year, the ...

O’Neill wants Trojans to improve in the second half

Kevin O’Neill was content with his debut but wouldn’t stand for his team’s imperfections. The new head coach of USC men’s basketball made that message loud ...

USC falls in its first road test

Coming into the third game of the season, sophomore Ashley Corral was charged with the difficult task of leading the USC women’s basketball team to ...

Williams’ playing chances are improving

Bye weeks present USC with an opportunity to get healthy, and this one is coming at just the right time. Four key USC players sat out ...

Carroll faces most difficult challenge yet

Nothing compares to the challenge facing coach Pete Carroll right now. Not preparing for an undefeated Oklahoma in the Orange Bowl. Not getting ready to face ...

Lifestyle

German director remains one of cinema’s finest weirdos

This story might not be true, but it’s alleged that during the filming of Fitzcarraldo in 1982, the great yet insane Polish actor Klaus Kinski, ...

A very LA birthday for Peter Bjorn and John

Few bands have the extensive résumé and indie credibility of Swedish pop-rock group Peter Bjorn and John. Even fewer bands in the current music industry ...

Herzog, Cage go off the deep end in ‘Lieutenant’

Take an eccentric director, add an eccentric star, and what’s the outcome? A truly bizarre film. In Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans, the combination of ...

Despite worthy attempt, play falls short in flavor

“Have you eaten yet?” is the way the Chinese greet each other, and that is the way Gloria B (Esther Scott) is greeted by Richie ...

Comedy highlights quirky ensemble cast

Writer, director and producer Sebastian Gutierrez adds indie comedy to his long résumé of thriller and horror films with Women in Trouble. Premiered at the 2009 ...

Flower mart an evergreen LA fixture

Hidden in the grid of Downtown Los Angeles, the LA Flower District boasts the title of largest flower wholesale district in the country. Comprised of ...