Kiffin, USC walking a very thin ethical line


A fake extra point gone awry in the first quarter of USC’s 50-6 victory over Colorado last Saturday serves as just the latest example of the Trojans’ alarming lapse in judgment when it comes to showing common courtesy for opponents.

Allow me to clarify.

Mind games · Against Colorado, sophomore quarterback Cody Kessler switched to No. 35 in an effort to throw off the Buffaloes. – Sean Roth | Daily Trojan

When USC lined up for the extra point with the score already at 13-0, a player wearing No. 35 positioned himself as the holder. But punter Kyle Negrete, who usually wears the number, wasn’t on the field.

Rather, backup quarterback Cody Kessler had been told by the coaching staff to swap jerseys before the game started. And on that play, he grabbed the snap and took off for the end zone, but the play was called off because of holding.

In the interest of full disclosure, I’m far from an avid defender of the many unwritten rules that exist in different sports. Plenty are steeped in traditions that make very little sense to anyone at present. But there remains a fine line between employing normal gamesmanship and doing something unethical. It’s worth pointing out, under coaching ethics in the official NCAA rulebook, “changing numbers during the game to deceive the opponent” is deemed as a number of unethical practices.

So USC’s deceptive use of jersey numbers, while not illegal, only compounds the Trojans’ penalty problems that seem to give off an impression of a lack of respect for the game’s most basic practices.

As Orange County Register writer Rich Hammond pointed out, USC stands as one of just a few remaining programs in the country without names on the backs of their jerseys. That’s a personal preference, not an excuse to take advantage of the situation to intentionally throw off another team.

USC was favored by more than 40 points entering its game against the one-win Buffaloes. They weren’t going to lose. Really want to go for two with the score sitting at 13-0? Probably not worth it, but I’m not going to argue with a surprise playcall when the game is still within reach. Once again, though, that fine line of gamesmanship enters the picture. A trick formation is one thing, taking advantage of an opportunity barely available to others for such a small payoff becomes another.

But the bigger problem here lies in the disconnect between what the coaching staff has been preaching and what’s happening on the field among players. Following the ejection of freshman defensive lineman Leonard Williams against Colorado — one of the day’s 10 penalties — USC coach Lane Kiffin said his team’s lack of composure was “a disgrace to the university.”

But that was nothing new for the Trojans, who lead the nation in penalties per contest. USC has been, without a doubt, an unruly football team for most of the season. Though they are committing an excess of false starts and offsides, these are completely preventable.

Kiffin can talk about how disappointed he is in the lack of discipline, but at some point the coaching staff has to take some of the blame as well. Bush-league moves like swapping Negrete’s jersey for Kessler’s only exacerbate the problem. It contributes to USC’s “dirty” image, which, despite the incredible amount of penalties, really isn’t a fair characterization.

Kiffin gets a bad rap for his stoic persona and “win at all costs” mentality, but for the most part, he’s been on his best behavior since returning to Los Angeles. No need to ruin that now over something so silly and unnecessary.

For the time being, USC’s consistent mental slip-ups and childish attempts at gaining an edge haven’t really cost them. But the first half of the team’s schedule was a walk in the park compared to what’s approaching.

Penalty yards add up, especially against teams capable of turning an extra first down into points. Kiffin and company need to focus and set a proper example for the rest of the team. If he really chides his players for making boneheaded mistakes, USC should be able clean up what has become an unexpected but mammoth flaw. The Trojans are simply too motivated to let one of the only things they can control during a game negatively affect them. And they’re too talented to have to resort to plays like the one in the early minutes of Saturday’s game.

 

“The Fifth Quarter” runs every other Wednesday. If you would like to comment on this story, visit DailyTrojan.com or email Alex at ajshultz@usc.edu.


  • 1982 Alumnus

    After USC’s stunning loss to Arizona, caused largely by the undisciplined actions of the players, it’s time to place the blame squarely on the shoulders of Lane Kiffin. He lacks the maturity and wisdom to control and command the respect of players who are behaving like juvenile delinquents. USC needs a grown man as head coach, not a kid who relies on his pop to help manage the team.

  • Cardinal

    Yet one more reason why it was so satisfying to see Stanford beat USC.

    • Parker

      It was also very satisfying watching UW beat Stanford.

  • jax4usc

    That this number-swapping story should even appear in the Daily Trojan Iindicates that the Trojan sense of sportsmanship has not totally disappeared from our tradition, at least in the Journalism School if not the McKay Center. The deceptive play wasn’t so much evil as it was childish. I suppose in defense of that notion is that Lane Kiffin is among the youngest head coaches in collegiate football. However, his father, Monty Kiffin, is a fully growed-up man and so is Athletic Director, Pat Haden. I’d like to read an interview with Haden on this matter. How ’bout it, Alex?

    JLH
    J-School, ’58

  • don’t agree

    Changing jerseys before the game is part of the game. Just like trick plays are part of the game. I personally liked it and found it clever and imaginative. Maybe if more teams kept names off the back of their jerseys and played as a team and not as individuals, they could do the same.

    • You’re joking right

      Clearly you know nothing of classy, respectable gamesmanship. To pull this in a game that clearly was going to be a blowout (-40 point favorite) looks horrible on the coaching staff.

  • Jerry Smith

    It is definitely illegal.. You should read more into the rule book… Page FR22… First line…

    http://cfo.arbitersports.com/Groups/104777/Library/files/Football%202012%20and%202013%20Rules%20and%20Interpretations.pdf

  • Steve B.

    Agree, the team lacks discipline. Kiffin is better suited for the NFL ( no fun league ). He plays not to lose since the first loss to Stanford figuring one more loss will eliminate team from a BCS major bowl game. Changing #’s was
    idiotic. Maybe figuring out a decent two-pt. play would be more appropriate.