Ending public television programs not the answer

By Daniel Killam · Daily Trojan

Posted March 7, 2011 at 8:04 pm in Opinion

The Republican Congress has recently taken to attacking discretionary spending with a buzzsaw, and one of the centerpiece cuts in its proposed budget is the elimination of government funding for the Corporation for Public Broadcasting. The move is merely the latest development in a long, bitter relationship between public television and the political right.

Though the CPB is an inviting, low-hanging fruit for budget hawks to target, cutting its funding is a politically harmful move, not only because the CPB enjoys broad public support, but also because public broadcasting is aligned with many classically conservative ideals.

Public television serves an important role in our society, one that is difficult to quantify monetarily.

Educational shows like Sesame Street teach children important values such as respect for others; public interest journalism from the likes of NewsHour and Frontline is the standard of unbiased reporting free of any agenda.

Shows like California’s Gold and Antiques Roadshow encourage a sense of pride in our great country’s history.

These programs are pillars of public television, an institution portrayed by many as a bastion of liberal propaganda. An editorial in the Washington Times called the CPB “a Great Society-era big-government dinosaur.” Opponents portray it as a parasite feeding off taxpayer dollars, or “the Muppet Lobby,” in the words of Sen. Jim DeMint (R-S.C.).

Other conservative representatives are more guarded in their criticism.

Rep. David Dreier (R-Calif.) professes to be a loyal fan of NPR and PBS, but said  America cannot afford the $451 million that go to the CPB every year. Apparently it has become politically safe to say  “viewers like you” should pick up the tab instead of Uncle Sam.

The CPB would be a valuable head to hang on the wall for Republicans seeking to appease their political base.

But although budget-obsessed tea partiers might see PBS as a neon target for drastic cuts, public television is a fundamental element in modern American society, and it deserves our public investment.

The big networks used to be bound by law to carry public interest programming in exchange for the right to broadcast on the publicly owned airwaves.

Networks gradually threw off those shackles as they realized the real profit was found in TV’s ability to sell, rather than in its status as a service.

They learned some customers are more valuable than others and began to value the demographics that were most susceptible to commercial messages. TV content became homogenous and less innovative.

Public television, for the most part, never traveled down that dangerous, slippery slope. Public interest news shows continued to cover issues they considered valuable, instead of fixating on the color of an Oscar nominee’s dress or Charlie Sheen’s mental state.

Sesame Street, Barney and Arthur continue to educate children about the values of kindness and understanding instead of simply drawing young minds from one commercial break to the next.

Several generations have now grown up with PBS, learning about the universe on Nova and tuning in to see Mr. Rogers tell us we all are special, just the way we are.

PBS will survive defunding by the federal government, but it might lose its public mission in the process. Profitable shows like Sesame Street and Nova will continue, but their success will not subsidize public interest programs such as Frontline and will not balance the books of small rural stations that rely on federal funds to serve their communities.

Public broadcasting has become an inexorable and priceless pillar of American life, and if we sacrifice it for the purpose of a few saved pennies, we will have sold a piece of ourselves in the process.

Daniel Killam is a junior majoring in environmental studies.

6 Comments on “Ending public television programs not the answer”

  1. Joe

    So how do you propose to pay for it?

    Oh yeah. By sending the bill to MY CHILDREN.

    Stop racking up debts that you expect others to pay for, and then we’ll talk about spending priorities. Deal?

  2. [...] pm in Opinion. 1 Star 2 Stars 3 Stars 4 Stars 5 Stars (No Ratings Yet). Loading . … Link: Ending public television programs not the answer | Daily Trojan Posted in Uncategorized Tags: answer, daily tv shows, daniel, daniel-killam, days-ago, [...]

  3. Christopher Ganiere

    NPR & CPB are small potatoes when you look at the overall budget. However, the federal government has taken to overspending MONTHLY revenues the by more than the ANNUAL budget of California. We are no longer so rich that we can afford such luxuries as these. We need to break loose these government sponsored entities and require them to pay their fair share of taxes like other broadcasters and corporations.

  4. jennifer rose

    I like cowboy poetry? Doesn’t everybody???

    I miss our local KCET station which used to play mystery theater, and all kinds of concerts.

    It’s a shame more people can’t appreciate public television which is such a tiny miniscule part of the budget.

    Thanks for the article.

    jennifer rose

  5. Diane

    Yes, and let’s be sure we keep funding cowboy poetry, too.

    The axe has to fall, my young friend, and NPR and CPB are wonderful places to cut. Let the free market sort out which programming will survive. I daresay that if there is an audience for Frontline type programming (and there is), those brave journalists will find work.

    You youngsters have had your minds so filled with leftist mush by your unionized teachers and left-wing professors that you can’t see straight. I find these DT editorial pieces endlessly amazing – that they can consistently produce such a lockstep left-wing view of the world. It’s astonishing! Are none of you brave enough to think for yourselves?

  6. student

    sesame street, arthur, and barney- teaching our kid morals??? How about the fact that these programs are really there to set up false idols to our impressionable youth- a golden calf for the modern age, if you will.
    what is barney, but a large, homosexual, talking lizard?

    DOWN with BARNEY, DOWN with SESAME STREET,DOWN with ARTHUR, the talking anteater!!!

More News

  Daily Trojan Spring Awakening Supplement

Blogs

Daily Trojan Poll

Which headliner did you enjoy most at Springfest?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Archives

March 2011
S M T W T F S
« Feb   Apr »
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Browse Archives

News

John Mork looks forward to giving back to USC

John Mork’s long relationship with USC came to a peak last Monday when USC announced that the B.S. ’70 and M.S. ’12 alumnus would become ...

Dept of Public Safety postpones reaccreditation

After submitting itself for reaccreditation from the International Association of Campus Law Enforcement Administrators, USC’s Dept. of Public Safety was granted a postponement of approximately ...

Roundup

The following incidents were reported in the USC Dept. of Public Safety Daily Incident Log between Monday, June 3, and Tuesday, June 4.  Crimes against property at ...

Opinion

Students must continue work on USChange

Many members of the USC community voiced their concern following the May 4 incident in which the Los Angeles Police Department shut down a party ...

Consider DNA to prevent future violence

On June 7, John Zawahri killed five people and injured five more at Santa Monica College. [caption id="attachment_67323" align="alignright" width="300"] Danny Razzano | Daily Trojan[/caption] As investigators ...

Will the new public school proposal help students?

Brown’s proposal is no cure-all, but offers long-awaited aid to the state’s most vulnerable students.  The end of May marks the latest round of revisions to ...

Sports

Steven Mitchell tears ACL in summer session

USC experienced some roster turnover this week that benefitted the squad’s defense but depleted the depth of what is considered by many to be the ...

Two Trojans selected in MLB Draft

Two USC baseball players were taken in the Major League Baseball draft conducted late last week. Junior infielder James Roberts was drafted in the 15th ...

Nellum dazzles one more time, coach Allice retires

Led by the outstanding performances of sprinters Bryshon Nellum and Aaron Brown, the USC men’s track and field team placed fifth with its most points ...

Lifestyle

Refn delivers style without substance in Only God Forgives

Only God Forgives, the second collaboration between director Nicolas Winding Refn and actor Ryan Gosling, fails to live up to the brilliance and intensity of ...

Alumna hits stride on YouTube

When USC alumna Mary Kate Wiles started her acting career, she never thought that she would find fame on the smaller silver screen. But thanks ...

Lenka lulls listeners with new album

Australian-born singer-songwriter Lenka Kripac — better known as Lenka — has produced yet another dynamic album: Shadows. Delivering a rich production of soothing melodies paired ...

Photos

In Photos: Washington comes to USC

In Photos: Washington comes to USC

The Schwarzenegger Institute held an immigration reform forum titled "Washington comes to USC", with U.S Senators John McCain, Michael Bennet and former President of Mexico ...

In Photos: Armenian Genocide

Photos by Ani Kolangian [gallery link="file" ids="66554,66555,66556,66557,66558,66559,66560,66561,66562"]

In Photos: Springfest 2013

Photos by Priyanka Patel. [gallery link="file" ids="65587,65586,65585,65584,65583,65582,65581,65580,65579,65578,65577,65576"]