New marriage proposal faces uphill battle

By Daniel Charnoff · Daily Trojan

Posted September 16, 2009 at 10:30 am in Opinion

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...

On Tuesday morning, three US congressmen held a press conference to announce the Respect for Marriage Act, a proposed law that would repeal the 1996 Defense of Marriage Act — which defines marriage as between a man and a woman.

At the conference, Rep. Jerrold Nadler (D-NY) said that same-sex couples “have debunked the baseless myth that their marriages would somehow undermine or destroy the institution of marriage. The sky has not fallen, as our opponents had argued it would.” The true harm of the law, he said, “is the harm it causes same-sex couples and their families.”

This is a bill that has very little chance of passing. Though it has 90 co-sponsors, they are all Democrats. There is also no comparable bill under consideration in the Senate, and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has indicated that repealing DOMA will be a low priority for her party. Additionally, openly gay Rep. Barney Frank (D-Mass.) has said that he does not believe that a repeal of DOMA could get through Congress anytime soon.

The unwillingness of Democratic leaders to push on this issue is understandable. They are in the midst of a bitter fight over health care reform, and it would probably be bad strategy for them to antagonize the Right any further. The passage of Proposition 8 last year in what is widely considered one of America’s most liberal states indicates the extent of the opposition to legalizing gay marriage, and the Democrats certainly do not want to awaken that sleeping giant and add to their current troubles.

However, just because something is understandable does not mean it is right. DOMA has always been, and continues to be, a system of codified discrimination against homosexuals. The US has traditionally prided itself on the protection that it offers to its minorities, but that stance is challenged by the hatred and fear-motivated popular resistance against allowing gays and lesbians to call themselves “married.”

Opponents of recognizing same-sex marriages often use apocalyptic arguments but, as Nadler mentioned, in the states in which homosexuals are allowed to get married, the sky has not fallen. Men and women still get married and have children, just like in every other state. In fact, those states — Massachusetts, Connecticut, Vermont and Iowa — are often stereotyped as places that do not face many of the social problems that exist in places where homosexuals are not permitted to express themselves on the same level as everyone else.

Opponents also like to say that repealing DOMA would harm “the sanctity of marriage.” This is the argument that I find most laughable. According to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, in 2009 there were nearly half as many divorces as marriages in our country. I think it is safe to say that whatever sanctity of marriage was inherited by our parents’ and grandparents’ generations has gone out the window by now. So, what exactly are we protecting?

I really believe that many of the people making these arguments see through them as much as I do. These polemics serve as facades for what is often simply fear and hatred of homosexuality — something that is as hard to debate as it is to overcome, and something that is a giant red flag for liberal-minded policymakers.

I have little doubt that our government’s discrimination against homosexuals will disappear with the passage of time. A May 2009 CNN/Opinion Research Corporation poll showed 54 percent of respondents opposed to same-sex marriage and 44 percent in favor of it; among 18- to 34-year-olds, 58 percent supported same-sex marriage. That percentage goes down as age rises, culminating in only 24 percent of Americans 65 and older supporting the recognition of same-sex marriages.

History shows that this pattern is a common one. In 1948, about 90 percent of American adults opposed legalizing interracial marriage. In 1967, the number was 72 percent, and only in 1991 did those opposed to it finally become a minority. As people who were raised to have a completely outdated outlook die and younger generations begin to dominate the population, public opinion shifts to demand a more tolerant and inclusive society.

But waiting for the inevitable is an unacceptable way of dealing with a problem when it means prolonging the pain that many homosexuals in America feel because their country tells them that something is wrong with them. Interracial marriage was legalized in California in 1948 and nationally in 1967, despite widespread opposition. Thanks to the brave efforts of those who fought for what was right, people who loved someone of a different race did not have to wait decades in order to get married just because that was how long it took for the inevitable to happen.

If this issue is something that you feel strongly about, do something. Write to your congressperson — especially if he or she is not one of the 90 co-sponsors of the Respect for Marriage Act. Talk to a friend or relative about same-sex marriage, because they may not know that our federal government has an official policy against it or that a sliver of opportunity exists to repeal the policy this year.

It is time for our representatives to stop waiting for the inevitable. The time is now to put official discrimination against homosexuals where it belongs — in the dustbin of history.

Daniel Charnoff is a junior majoring in international relations (global business).

Comments are closed.

More News

2012 USG Elections Coverage

Daily Trojan Poll

What is your reaction to the news of CNN host Christiane Amanpour speaking at commencement?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Archives

Browse Archives

News

USC neighbors complain about off-campus parties

USC neighbors complain about off-campus parties

More and more students are living in the area around campus, according to Student Affairs, and a larger number of students are interacting with community ...

Roundup

The following incidents were reported in the USC Department of Public Safety daily incident log on Wednesday, Feb. 8.Miscellaneous incidentsat 11:01 p.m., DPS officers responded ...

CET holds workshop on research

The Center for Excellence in Teaching hosted an event Thursday to inform students about obtaining research opportunities.The event, Now You Know: How To Get Research, ...

Cheers

Guests gather in the Social Science Building for a wine tasting and lecture by Lester Little, an emeritus professor of history and former president of ...

Scholars to use academics on global stage

This spring, the Dornsife Scholars Program will honor outstanding graduating seniors who have bridged academic achievement with concerns for positive human impact.The new Dornsife Scholars ...

USG Elections: Video Interviews

Videos edited by Alexis Driggs | Daily Trojan Mikey Geragos/Vinnie PrasadJared Ginsburg/Sam CoxeTheo Offei and Julia Riley

Opinion

What should US foreign involvement look like?

What should US foreign involvement look like?

America’s economy isn’t doing so hot right now. But once upon a time, it was thriving beyond what most people thought was possible. The nation ...

What should US foreign involvement look like?

We are facing dire times in America. With war in Afghanistan and potential nuclear proliferation in Iran, our government has its hands full, and our ...

Perfect is overrated, not worth the effort

“Nobody’s perfect.” It’s a popular and common phrase, but it hasn’t stopped anyone from trying.Someone who takes the SAT twice with the goal of scoring ...

Politics must not compromise health

Do you know anyone who has suffered from breast cancer? Are you at risk? It’s hard to find someone who hasn’t been affected by the ...

Café 84 will serve us better as a dining hall

EVK Restaurant and Grill has only three options you can really count on: chicken nugget Tuesdays, Caesar salad and French fries. These foods are among ...

City has a right to Occupy LA protest murals

The public tends to view graffiti negatively; it is often washed away almost as quickly as it appears. Graffiti, however, can take a wide variety ...

Sports

Trojans to face Pepperdine at home

The No. 6 USC Trojans men’s volleyball team is gearing up to play No. 10 Pepperdine at home tonight after a stunning loss at the ...

No. 12 Pepperdine to host No. 1 Trojans

Following two resounding road wins over No. 6 Stanford and No. 13 California, USC men’s tennis will tackle one more opponent before the ITA National ...

Trojans need a freshman sensation

For more than 50 years, the USC men’s basketball team called the Los Angeles Memorial Sports Arena home.A landmark on its own, sure, but over ...

Cardinal win big over USC

There’s a reason Stanford is among the upper echelon of women’s college basketball.  The Cardinal showed why it’s reached the past four Final Fours in ...

Trojans fall to Bears at Galen

The USC men’s basketball team dropped its third straight game on Thursday night, falling to California 75-49 at the Galen Center. The loss marked USC’s ...

Lifestyle

Variety boosts fitness

Variety boosts fitness

The spring semester is heading into the thick of assignments and projects, meaning more stress and less free time.It’s important, however, that students continue to ...

Bands bounce back from loss of members

Paramore, Green Day and MxPx have lost at least one founding member. But these bands have redefined themselves and have emerged stronger than ever.When bands ...

Play provides social commentary on race

Clybourne Park, winner of the 2011 Pulitzer Prize for drama, will head to Broadway April 19, but not before finishing its superb run at the ...

Bakeries present quality treats for sweet tooths

First came the cupcake. Bakeries frosted, filled, topped, decorated and supersized the individual treats until there wasn’t much left  to be done.Following suit as the ...

Trendy juice bar proves too costly

Moon Juice, a new juice shop in Venice, conjures the same feeling as Alex Trebek’s pronunciation of French words on Jeopardy!: mild admiration, moderate apprehension ...

Photos

Slideshow: St. Vincent de Paul Catholic Church

Slideshow: St. Vincent de Paul Catholic Church

This year, the nearby St. Vincent de Paul Catholic Church parish celebrates its 125th anniversary. St. Vincent de Paul, located on Figueroa Street and Adams ...

This Week in Photos: Jan. 30 – Feb. 3

"This Week in Photos" highlights the biggest stories of the week.Trojans upend Utah to end losing streak>>[caption id="attachment_44062" align="aligncenter" width="614" caption="Worth the wait · Sophomore ...

Slideshow: Spring Awakening

Selling out just 36 hours after reservations opened, Cardinal Theatre Productions’ presentation of the rock musical Spring Awakening had to meet some pretty big expectations. ...

Slideshow: USC Men’s Basketball vs. Utah

The USC men’s basketball team put an end to a nine-game losing streak on Saturday night with a decisive 62-45 victory over the Utah Utes ...

Slideshow: USC Women’s Basketball vs. Oregon

The Women of Troy had let a 13-point halftime lead slip all the way down to one in the second half. The Ducks were surging ...