Many on fence for health care reform

By Robert Fragosa · Daily Trojan

Posted October 15, 2009 at 7:26 pm in Columns, Opinion

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (Votes: 2; Avg: 1.00)
Loading ... Loading ...

Growing up in largely Latino Southern Arizona directly exposed me to how a large portion of the population deals with their health care needs — they drive for 45 minutes down to south of the border to take advantage of less expensive health care and pharmaceuticals.

Oct 16th 09

Andrew Laskowski|Daily Trojan

Has American health care become so expensive that we have to outsource medical care, too?

A recent study conducted by the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research found that an estimated 1 million Californians seek medical, dental or prescription coverage in Mexico each year.

The fact that 46.3 million people remain uninsured is a clear sign that the current system isn’t beneficial to everyone. Working a low-income job with limited or no health benefits doesn’t suddenly diminish a person’s health care needs, nor does it lower the cost. Doctors across the border understand this and capitalize on the medical visits to Mexico.

Interestingly enough, Latino US citizens account for only half of the citizens traveling across the border for health care, which costs roughly a little less than half of what it would cost in the United States without insurance. The trip south is suddenly a little less inconvenient when parents can pay $2,400 for their children’s braces as opposed to the minimum $5,000 it would cost in the US.

The incentive to travel south rises when considering that 62 percent of all personal bankruptcies in 2007 were caused by health problems. Shockingly, 71 percent of those that filed for bankruptcy were covered.

Steps were taken on Tuesday when congressional committees endorsed a bill for health care reform. The legislation, which faces major hurdles before it will hit the Senate floor for debate by the end of the month, looks to expand Medicaid and federal subsidies for lower-income families, as well as keep a harsher tab on insurance companies.

Legislation is far from complete, and only one member of the GOP, Maine Sen. Olympia Snowe, currently endorses the bill. It may be a while before many Americans can find affordable coverage above the border.

Border-hopping for treatment carries its fair share of risks. Primarily, there’s a lack of access to malpractice insurance coverage. If a procedure goes wrong, liability could go out the window.

These concerns are enough to keep most Americans away from Mexico for their health care needs, but, when push comes to shove, people are more prone to take the only risk they can afford. A $21,000 heart bypass is certainly more accessible than the up to $144,000 it can cost in the United States.

Price disparities don’t need to be so high. Japan, which has the highest life expectancy in the world, pays $2,581 annually per person; the United States pays a staggering $7,290 with a life expectancy that only ranks 42nd internationally.

The fact remains that citizens shouldn’t have to foreclose on their homes to pay for surgery, or else go across the border to get it. Yet conservatives still cry that letting the government take over health care gives them that much more power over citizens, as demonstrated by the paltry support for the comprehensive reform.

Instead of giving the power to a $2.3-trillion industry run by insurance companies that can discriminate against anyone with preexisting health conditions, the government can and should step in. And they’re trying to.

For those that disagree with the platform of extended health care, take a walk in the shoes of the 15.4 percent of Americans without health insurance. That’s entering a pool where 45,000 will die annually because they are uninsured — one needless death every 12 minutes.

Citizens should not have to put up with this discrepancy. It’s the people in these situations that Obama set out to help, and it’s these people who are going to suffer if the health care reform doesn’t pass.

Lobbyists for the insurance industry, however, are making their best efforts to stop it, out of fear for lost profits. They strategically released a report one day before a critical senate vote on the matter, arguing the plan could cost families $4,000 more than expected in 2019.

Lobbyists neglected to mention that, with premiums rising at three times the rate of wages, families can expect to pay $24,000 per year by 2016 under the system currently in place.

The government is hardly criticized for building roads or funding schools, but, for some reason, trying to give everyone reasonable health care coverage is out of line. Isn’t our health, though, more important than anything else? It’s not as if people are advocating socialism, increased government size or rampant debt — yet many are treating the situation that way.

Fortunately, Southern Californians don’t have to worry about this dilemma because people here have access to affordable health care already. They just have to go to Mexico to get it.

Robert Fragoza is a junior majoring in chemical engineering. His column, “Reality Check,” runs Fridays.

3 Comments on “Many on fence for health care reform”

  1. Diane

    Fragoza’s article is almost astonishingly simple-minded. The biggest reason for astronomical medical costs in the U.S. is out-of-control tort lawyers (think: John Edwards). What’s more, getting the government completely OUT of the medical business is what would truly force insurance companies to compete for customers on a broad base which would force them to cater to markets now not served. It’s really pretty simple, would cost virtually nothing, and has not been tried. Why are liberals so damn afraid to give THAT a shot? Because they’re all about grabbing more power and control, some would argue. It has nothing to do with “change” as the dimwitted Mr. Degan mentions, above. It’s about doing something that will actually work. And PS — the U.S. CANNOT AFFORD the medical care plan Obama is pushing. Hello? Talk about mass stupidity.

  2. Christopher Ganiere

    The United States bosts the most complicated health care system in the world. We have every option available. Our states offer free care, subsidized care, and expensive care. Our employers offer free care, subsidized care, and expensive care. We have free clinics, subsidized clinics and expensive clinics. We have insurance companies that offer health plans allowed by law in many price ranges.
    We have so many choices that our lawmakers want to get rid of most of them.
    Our lawmakers could make great strides in simplifying the health care system by unbundeling it form the tax system. Instead of giving companies and unions tax breaks for whatever they give to employees, they could tax it like income. Companies and unions would soon find that it is cheaper to let individuals shop for the plan that suits them best rather than the companies and unions shopping for the cheapest plan for their bottom line.

  3. Tom Degan

    My younger brother Jeff is the shame of the Degan family. He not only lives in France, he actually likes it there. He has a French wife and two gorgeous little French daughters. Honestly I think the guy is a closet commie. Back in August, in a letter to his fellow countrymen and women regarding health care – or “Hell Care” as he called it (What a card!) – he ended it by saying:

    “In short, in the US, you pay more, get less, and die younger than we do in Europe. What part of that don’t you understand?”

    Well, hey there! That’s a danged good question! What part of that don’t we understand? Why is it that so many of us have to be dragged, kicking and screaming like half-witted little preschoolers, into the brave new world of change? What the hell is the matter with us anyway? How can it be that such a huge number of Americans cheerfully join movements of mass stupidity and salivate on cue to the sound of Dr. Glenn “Pavlov” Beck’s bell? It kind of makes you wonder, huh?

    http://www.tomdegan.blogspot.com

    Tom Degan
    Goshen, NY

More News

2012 USG Elections Coverage

Daily Trojan Poll

What is your reaction to the news of CNN host Christiane Amanpour speaking at commencement?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Browse Archives

News

USC neighbors complain about off-campus parties

USC neighbors complain about off-campus parties

More and more students are living in the area around campus, according to Student Affairs, and a larger number of students are interacting with community ...

Roundup

The following incidents were reported in the USC Department of Public Safety daily incident log on Wednesday, Feb. 8.Miscellaneous incidentsat 11:01 p.m., DPS officers responded ...

CET holds workshop on research

The Center for Excellence in Teaching hosted an event Thursday to inform students about obtaining research opportunities.The event, Now You Know: How To Get Research, ...

Cheers

Guests gather in the Social Science Building for a wine tasting and lecture by Lester Little, an emeritus professor of history and former president of ...

Scholars to use academics on global stage

This spring, the Dornsife Scholars Program will honor outstanding graduating seniors who have bridged academic achievement with concerns for positive human impact.The new Dornsife Scholars ...

USG Elections: Video Interviews

Videos edited by Alexis Driggs | Daily Trojan Mikey Geragos/Vinnie PrasadJared Ginsburg/Sam CoxeTheo Offei and Julia Riley

Opinion

What should US foreign involvement look like?

What should US foreign involvement look like?

America’s economy isn’t doing so hot right now. But once upon a time, it was thriving beyond what most people thought was possible. The nation ...

What should US foreign involvement look like?

We are facing dire times in America. With war in Afghanistan and potential nuclear proliferation in Iran, our government has its hands full, and our ...

Perfect is overrated, not worth the effort

“Nobody’s perfect.” It’s a popular and common phrase, but it hasn’t stopped anyone from trying.Someone who takes the SAT twice with the goal of scoring ...

Politics must not compromise health

Do you know anyone who has suffered from breast cancer? Are you at risk? It’s hard to find someone who hasn’t been affected by the ...

Café 84 will serve us better as a dining hall

EVK Restaurant and Grill has only three options you can really count on: chicken nugget Tuesdays, Caesar salad and French fries. These foods are among ...

City has a right to Occupy LA protest murals

The public tends to view graffiti negatively; it is often washed away almost as quickly as it appears. Graffiti, however, can take a wide variety ...

Sports

Trojans to face Pepperdine at home

The No. 6 USC Trojans men’s volleyball team is gearing up to play No. 10 Pepperdine at home tonight after a stunning loss at the ...

No. 12 Pepperdine to host No. 1 Trojans

Following two resounding road wins over No. 6 Stanford and No. 13 California, USC men’s tennis will tackle one more opponent before the ITA National ...

Trojans need a freshman sensation

For more than 50 years, the USC men’s basketball team called the Los Angeles Memorial Sports Arena home.A landmark on its own, sure, but over ...

Cardinal win big over USC

There’s a reason Stanford is among the upper echelon of women’s college basketball.  The Cardinal showed why it’s reached the past four Final Fours in ...

Trojans fall to Bears at Galen

The USC men’s basketball team dropped its third straight game on Thursday night, falling to California 75-49 at the Galen Center. The loss marked USC’s ...

Lifestyle

Variety boosts fitness

Variety boosts fitness

The spring semester is heading into the thick of assignments and projects, meaning more stress and less free time.It’s important, however, that students continue to ...

Bands bounce back from loss of members

Paramore, Green Day and MxPx have lost at least one founding member. But these bands have redefined themselves and have emerged stronger than ever.When bands ...

Play provides social commentary on race

Clybourne Park, winner of the 2011 Pulitzer Prize for drama, will head to Broadway April 19, but not before finishing its superb run at the ...

Bakeries present quality treats for sweet tooths

First came the cupcake. Bakeries frosted, filled, topped, decorated and supersized the individual treats until there wasn’t much left  to be done.Following suit as the ...

Trendy juice bar proves too costly

Moon Juice, a new juice shop in Venice, conjures the same feeling as Alex Trebek’s pronunciation of French words on Jeopardy!: mild admiration, moderate apprehension ...

Photos

Slideshow: St. Vincent de Paul Catholic Church

Slideshow: St. Vincent de Paul Catholic Church

This year, the nearby St. Vincent de Paul Catholic Church parish celebrates its 125th anniversary. St. Vincent de Paul, located on Figueroa Street and Adams ...

This Week in Photos: Jan. 30 – Feb. 3

"This Week in Photos" highlights the biggest stories of the week.Trojans upend Utah to end losing streak>>[caption id="attachment_44062" align="aligncenter" width="614" caption="Worth the wait · Sophomore ...

Slideshow: Spring Awakening

Selling out just 36 hours after reservations opened, Cardinal Theatre Productions’ presentation of the rock musical Spring Awakening had to meet some pretty big expectations. ...

Slideshow: USC Men’s Basketball vs. Utah

The USC men’s basketball team put an end to a nine-game losing streak on Saturday night with a decisive 62-45 victory over the Utah Utes ...

Slideshow: USC Women’s Basketball vs. Oregon

The Women of Troy had let a 13-point halftime lead slip all the way down to one in the second half. The Ducks were surging ...