Charity should not depend on death tolls
Two major earthquakes have devastated Haiti and Chile in the last two months. Thousands have died and many more displaced with destruction overtaking the respective countries. One country was better equipped than the other for these natural disasters, but both quakes have left residents with a lack of resources necessary for survival ‚ÄĒ raising the question, should one life outweigh another?
Between 200,000 and 250,000 people died in Haiti and more than 1 million were displaced, according to the Wall Street Journal. It‚Äôs estimated that the country suffered more than $8.1 billion in damages. Millions of Americans have sympathetically risen to the occasion and donated millions of dollars to Haiti since the 7.0-magnitude earthquake occurred in January. USC students have also done their part by assembling relief kits for survivors and hosting benefit events.
Because Haiti is a developing country and did not have the resources to prepare itself for an earthquake, it suffered greater consequences than Chile.
Despite the differences in damage, Chileans are still in great need of resources and should not be neglected; nearly 800 people died in last week‚Äôs 8.8-magnitude earthquake. The Wall Street Journal said the Feb. 27 earthquake has been deemed one of the largest earthquakes in a century. So why aren‚Äôt people coming to Chile‚Äôs rescue like they did for Haiti?
Could the lack in motivation be caused by the economic downturn and a depletion of resources after Americans gave their extra money to Haiti?
Doubtful ‚ÄĒ people kindly donated whatever they could to Haiti by calling, text messaging and sending checks to the Red Cross and other relief organizations.
‚ÄúI think enough of us have, even through a recession, some disposable income that we can contribute to … Chile,‚ÄĚ said Justin Lacey, a junior majoring in finance and accounting.
‚ÄúI think that people do whatever their hearts tell them to do,‚ÄĚ said Taira Sims, an undecided freshman.
CNN reported that actor George Clooney helped organize a benefit telethon, which aired on more than 25 networks and raised millions of dollars, to encourage Americans to donate money to Haiti.
Between 130 and 140 celebrities performed and picked up telephones at the event, Clooney told The Associated Press.
‚ÄúThe main thing about charity is that if you make it cool anyone will do anything,‚ÄĚ said Jack Robbins, a junior majoring in cinema-television production. ‚ÄúI gave half a grand to Haiti because Radiohead made a concert and I went. If there‚Äôs a smart marketing campaign like there was for Haiti, anything is possible.‚ÄĚ
It has been almost a week since the earthquake, so why haven‚Äôt I heard of any events taking place to help Chilean victims recover?
Commercials are not encouraging me to text a number in order to donate $10 to Chile, and news stations have not put a number at the bottom of the screen to spur donations. USC residence halls are collecting materials to help Haiti but not Chile. What‚Äôs the deal? Do we really need to be told by celebrities to help out?
At an event hosted at Ground Zero Performance Caf√© ¬†on Tuesday night, USC students took the bull by the horns and made contributions to both Haiti and Chile.
According to Glen Hsia, a senior majoring in music industry and one of the event‚Äôs organizers, the event featured student musicians and asked for donations to the American Red Cross and Invisible Children, an organization that benefits poverty-stricken children in Africa. Students had the choice of making donations to either Haiti or Chile, or specifically to the American Red Cross or Invisible Children.
As of yesterday, the American Red Cross is accepting donations specifically for Chile and has upped its initial pledge of $50,000 to $250,000. That‚Äôs a start.
Although the devastation in Chile cannot be equated with that in Haiti by any means, Chile still deserves the same kind of outpouring of aid witnessed in the response to the earthquake in Haiti. Chile‚Äôs buildings and infrastructure generally remained intact whereas Haiti‚Äôs were demolished, but 800 Chilean deaths is still too large a number to ignore. The need for aid in Chile, in addition to that in Haiti, must be recognized.
There is still a great demand for resources to assist both countries. The Ground Zero event is one of the first I have noticed on campus that is raising money for Chile as well as Haiti.
Hopefully in the next few days higher profile organizations will follow suit.
Danielle Nisimov is a sophomore¬†majoring in public relations. Her¬†column ‚ÄúOn the SCene‚ÄĚ runs Thursdays.