Obama fails to capitalize on Egypt


One of the persistent questions surrounding the waves of protest spreading across the Muslim world has been how the United States should respond.

The Obama administration is attempting to balance a number of concerns in crafting its stance on Egypt, Tunisia, Yemen and the increasingly unstable environment in Jordan and Syria.

Julia Vann | Daily Trojan

Among these concerns  are America’s commitment to democracy and human rights, the need to avoid angering any governments that survive, concern for major allies, such as Israel and Saudi Arabia, and a desire to maintain a positive  international image.

So far, it seems the administration’s main priority has been to avoid “rocking the boat.” All public statements about the protests, especially those in Egypt, have been  subdued and conservative.

Two major lessons from the last few weeks indicate this is not the appropriate response at this juncture. The first is that there is a clear trend toward popular participation and democracy in the Middle East, a region where a justifiably discontent population will not submit to the rule of a few autocrats for much longer.

The second lesson is that half-measures are bound to fail. Dictators in Tunisia, Egypt, Yemen and Jordan have all made small concessions that did not placate their detractors, who will be stopped only by either a resignation or a terrible show of force, á  la Tiananmen.

There is only one way for the United States and its allies  to come out ahead in this situation: They must stay ahead of the trend.

The protests in North Africa and the Middle East are not about America. Some people have said  this is a reason for Obama to stay quiet, but there is a way to speak out without becoming the center of the storm.

Turkish Prime Minister Recep Erdogan did it, publicly calling for Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak to step down to preserve his legacy. As a result, when Mubarak finally leaves, Egypt’s new government will likely be friendly to Turkey and see Erdogan as an ally.

Obama could do the same thing, and it would make him massively more popular on the Egyptian streets. Though Obama has finally called for a transition of power, it is unclear why Obama did not assume leadership on such a critical international issue.

It is beginning to appear that Obama’s late reaction to changing events on the ground in Egypt and elsewhere is reflective of an ironically characteristic fault of his administration: a failure to capitalize on moments of change.

Obama entered office promising change, and he has largely delivered. His healthcare reform bill was considered one of the most important pieces of legislation in decades by supporters and opponents alike. The balance of power between Wall Street and Washington has been altered significantly. The war in Iraq is over, and the one in Afghanistan is making gradual progress.

Dr. William Bridges, author of Managing Transition, notes, “When a business or industry is going through a profound transformation — and there is hardly one that is not doing so today — competition blinds people to the real challenge, which is capitalizing on that change.”

If there is one systemic problem with the Obama administration so far, it has been its failure to heed Bridges’ advice.

All too often, it seems that the President is covering his tracks instead of boldly embracing trends.

Egypt’s budding revolution seems to be another example of this type of failure. The United States could frame this as a victory for all of the ideals we claim to hold, celebrate it, then use our support for Egypt’s protest movement to strengthen international perceptions of our government and ease relations with Arab countries after they transition to democracy.

Instead, we are left playing catch-up again, and will be sure to pay the price for it down the road.

Daniel Charnoff is a senior majoring in international relations (global business). His column, “Through the Static,” runs Fridays.

For more stories on the crisis in Egypt, click here.

4 replies
  1. Arafat
    Arafat says:

    The only way for the people of the Middle East (all of Islam for that matter) to experience true democracy is to free themselves from the shackles of Islam.
    Islam and democracy are incompatible and anyone who says Indonesia is an example they are simply showing just how dire Islamic democracies are.
    Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Jordan, Oman, Syria, Lebanon, Sudan, Mauritania, Niger, Algeria, Somalia, Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Kirgizstan, etc…
    Name one country from this or any list of Islamic dominated countries where one can freely criticize Islam, convert from Islam, proselytize for any other religion, draw pictures of Mohammed, criticize Saudi Arabia, openly practice homosexuality or Judaism, be a free woman with all this implies.
    So please don’t blame Egypt’s problems on America. I would bet money that if America could foster true democracy in any Muslim country it would, just as it fostered freedoms and democracy in Germany and Japan after WWII.
    Quit blaming their problems on anyone but them and their backwards-looking religion.
    Finally, let me say, Mohammed was Islam’s first political leader. He refused to acknowledge a separation of mosque and state as Jesus did (Render unto Caesar that which is Caesar’s…). Mohammed was a theocratic despot who killed, raped, enslaved and pillaged his way to power and wealth.
    This is who Muslims look to for direction, no? Not to America, but to Mohammed and therein lies the tale of the tape.

  2. Duly Noted
    Duly Noted says:

    The reason Obama isn’t “capitalizing” on this “moment of change” is because it would be profoundly stupid to do so. Every other ally we have in the region (besides Israel, which is the only democracy) would realize that our support and friendship is only temporary, and have no incentive to cooperate with us or uphold our interests. If we supported uprisings every time they happened in the Middle East, we’d have no friends.

    No president or policy maker would seriously support the overly simplistic ideal set forth in this article.

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. […] Obama fails to capitalize on Egypt – Daily Trojan Online Posted in Arab Revolution | Tagged angeles-times, daily-trojan, egypt, our-government, relations-with, rival-rallies, street, street-journal Cancel Reply […]

Comments are closed.