Is Stand Your Ground a justifiable law? (Counterpoint)

By Sarah Cueva · Daily Trojan

Posted March 29, 2012 at 8:51 pm in Columns, Opinion

The killing of Trayvon Martin last month temporarily united both political parties, as President Barack Obama and GOP presidential candidates lamented the teenager’s death.

The issue has become politicized, however, as the debate over whether Florida’s Stand Your Ground self-defense law was responsible for Martin’s death.

The law itself has been put on the defensive as George Zimmerman managed to avoid prosecution by claiming that he shot Martin in self-defense.

Christina Ellis | Daily Trojan

Regardless of whether Zimmerman believed his actions were protected by the Stand Your Ground law, it is imperative that citizens have the right to protect themselves by use of force if they are attacked.

Following a 39-0 vote in the Florida Senate, then-Gov. Jeb Bush signed Stand Your Ground into law in 2005. The law grants citizens the right to use lethal force in self-defense if an attacker threatens them “unlawfully and forcefully.” Unless authorities can prove the person did not act in self-defense, that person is immune to criminal prosecution and civil suit under the law.

The high-profile and tragic nature of the Martin case has prompted the GOP presidential field to not only extend their condolences but to defend the vilified Florida law as compatible with a pro-gun rights agenda.

In an interview with Piers Morgan last week, Newt Gingrich stated that the law should not be applicable to the case. Gingrich opined that Zimmerman’s pursuit of Martin was not about “[standing] your own ground” but about “[chasing] the other person into their ground.”

Though Gingrich is right to assert that we do not know the full details of what happened, Martin’s unjust and untimely death should not be attributed to the law.

Putting aside the important question of whether Zimmerman acted in self-defense, the idea behind Florida’s law should be codified in every state as an affirmation of our constitutional right to bear arms.

Government has shown time and time again that it cannot be relied upon for everything. We must be especially cautious in guarding our lives instead of depending on the government to do it for us. The police are not infallible.

This is not to say that guns should be passed out on street corners. People should meet certain requirements before they can access firearms. But once they are legal gun owners, they should be able to use them to defend their lives.

There is no question that what happened to Martin is utterly horrible, but we cannot allow opportunistic political rhetoric to blame his death on anything other than the actions of a depraved man.

 

Sarah Cueva is a sophomore majoring in Middle East studies and political science. Point/Counterpoint runs Fridays.

 

For another perspective on this topic, click here. 

2 Comments on “Is Stand Your Ground a justifiable law? (Counterpoint)”

  1. whirligig

    I would love the right to go out and snipe people that “I was in fear of my life from”! I can name two just off the top of my head! can we have that law in California? please? pretty please?
    great article………. keep em comin Sarah!

  2. Jax4usc

    Sarah,

    Your entire peice is based on stuff that has not yet been released to the public. Save your emotional reaction for the facts to be known–what say?

    Jax4USC,

    Journ ’58

More News

  Daily Trojan Spring Awakening Supplement

Blogs

Daily Trojan Poll

Which headliner did you enjoy most at Springfest?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Archives

March 2012
S M T W T F S
« Feb   Apr »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Browse Archives

News

Dr. Dre, Iovine give $70 mil for new academy

A new type of undergraduate experience will be added to the university as music icons Jimmy Iovine and Dr. Dre are together giving $70 million ...

UPDATE: LAPD, DPS hold open forum for students

Video from the scene, courtesy of USC Black Student Assembly.   Students, alumni, faculty and community members voiced their concerns at an emotional open forum between the ...

Students hold sit-in in response to LAPD presence at party

[gallery link="file" ids="67092,67091,67090,67089,67088,67087,67086,67085,67084"] Photos by Razan Al Marzouqi   More than 100 students gathered in front of Tommy Trojan for a sit-in Monday afternoon in response to events ...

Opinion

Syrian conflict explodes

On May 16, President Barack Obama told the public about evidence that shows chemical weapons being used in the ongoing Syrian crisis, according to BBC ...

Extra-curriculars, internships as important as grades

As summertime rolls around and the sun and ocean begin to beckon eager pupils, one last roadblock stands in the way of true vacation bliss: ...

’SC sets example in lowering dropout rate

A report sponsored by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation reveals that the nation’s higher education system is facing a dropout crisis. Produced in part ...

Sports

Women of Troy fall in the round of 16

With a 15-match winning streak against the Cardinal and after bouncing the team from the NCAA quarterfinals last season, the No. 5 USC women’s tennis ...

Trojans can’t pull off unprecedented ‘5-peat’

An outstanding four-year championship run ended for the USC men’s tennis program on Saturday, May 18, in Urbana, Ill., as the No. 4 Trojans were ...

USC suffers sweep to rival UCLA

When USC and UCLA took the field this weekend for their annual three-game clash, it was hard to envision two more different teams and programs. ...

Lifestyle

Midnight builds on strengths of preceding films

Movie trilogies have a bit of a reputation for being films that rely heavily on action and excitement. They’re usually big money earners, which is ...

An Exercise in Authenticity

Though Generation Um
includes a star studded cast—Keanu Reeves, Bojana Novakovic, and Adelaide Clemens—this film surprisingly has more of an indie vibe.  Set in New York ...

History behind shakes

Though finals loom as obstacles between now and summer, Ground Zero Performance Café has the perfect solution for both cooling down and serving your study ...

Photos

In Photos: Washington comes to USC

In Photos: Washington comes to USC

The Schwarzenegger Institute held an immigration reform forum titled "Washington comes to USC", with U.S Senators John McCain, Michael Bennet and former President of Mexico ...

In Photos: Armenian Genocide

Photos by Ani Kolangian [gallery link="file" ids="66554,66555,66556,66557,66558,66559,66560,66561,66562"]

In Photos: Springfest 2013

Photos by Priyanka Patel. [gallery link="file" ids="65587,65586,65585,65584,65583,65582,65581,65580,65579,65578,65577,65576"]